Brick is the one exterior color you usually can't change — so a good brick house color scheme starts with the brick and builds around it. This guide covers exterior color combinations for the three brick situations Charlotte homeowners actually have: classic red brick colonials, brown and tan brick ranches, and brick that's already been painted. Every scheme here is a trim + shutter + door recipe you can hand to a painter, and the cost of executing it is far lower than most people assume.
What colors go with a brick house?
Build the scheme around the brick's undertone: red brick pairs best with warm white or cream trim and black, deep green, or navy shutters; brown brick wants earthy creams, olives, and bronze accents; painted brick opens the full palette. Updating only trim, shutters, and the door is the budget move — HomeGuide puts exterior trim at $1,000 to $2,500 and shutters at $400 to $1,200 for a whole house, versus $2,000 to $8,000 to paint the brick itself.
- Match trim to mortar, not to the brick
- Shutters: black, deep green, or navy for red brick
- Black front doors linked to ~$6,449 resale premium (Zillow)
- Trim refresh: $1,000–$2,500 vs $2,000–$8,000 to paint brick (HomeGuide)
Start With the Brick's Undertone
Hold a plain white sheet of paper against your brick in daylight and ask one question: does the brick lean orange, red-purple, brown, or pink? That undertone — plus the mortar color — decides more of your scheme than any paint chip will.
- Orange-leaning red brick (most common in post-war Charlotte ranches): needs warm trim; cool bright whites make it look rusty.
- Deep red or red-purple brick (common on colonials and Georgians): handles higher contrast — crisp whites and true black both work.
- Brown, tan, or buff brick (1960s–80s ranches and split-levels): wants low contrast and earth tones, not gray.
- Multi-tone or "blend" brick: pull your trim color from the lightest brick in the blend and your accent from the darkest.
- Mortar color is the cheat code — white mortar supports white trim, gray mortar supports greige and stone tones, buff mortar supports cream.
The Three-Part Scheme: Trim, Shutters, Door
Because the brick is the fixed "body" color, a brick house scheme has three moving parts. Keep the roles straight and almost any combination below will look intentional:
- Trim (fascia, soffits, window surrounds, porch posts): the quiet supporting color. It should relate to the mortar.
- Shutters: the depth color. Darker than the brick, never a near-miss of the brick's own color.
- Front door: the personality color. This is the one place a brick house can take a saturated hue.
One rule prevents most mistakes: never put a red-family color next to red brick unless it matches almost exactly. A rust door or maroon shutter that's "close but not quite" reads as a mismatch from the street.
Color Schemes for Red Brick Houses
Red brick is the workhorse of Charlotte's housing stock — from 1950s ranches in Madison Park and Cotswold to 1990s two-story colonials in Ballantyne and Union County. These four schemes cover the range:
Classic Colonial
SW Alabaster trim, black shutters and door (SW Tricorn Black). The default for deep red brick two-stories — high contrast, hard to date.
Southern Traditional
Cream trim (SW Shoji White or BM Navajo White) with deep green shutters and door (BM Essex Green). Warmer and softer than black on orange-leaning brick.
Updated Classic
BM White Dove trim with navy shutters and door (BM Hale Navy or SW Naval). A notch more current than black without leaving traditional territory.
Ranch Modernized
Greige trim (SW Agreeable Gray family), no shutters or charcoal (SW Iron Ore), wood-stained door. Suits low-slung ranches where shutters feel pasted on.
What to Skip on Red Brick
- Cool, bright white trim on orange-leaning brick — it exaggerates the orange.
- Burgundy or rust shutters — the near-miss problem.
- Light gray everything — gray trim next to warm red brick usually reads lavender.
Fast quote path
Send exterior photos. We will flag prep and repair scope.
If you are close to hiring, do not wait for a perfect form. Share the basics and we can route the project into the right estimate path for Charlotte.
Best details to send
About 200 reviews across Google & Thumbtack · Owner-led team
Color Schemes for Brown and Tan Brick
Brown brick is where most scheme advice falls apart, because the internet defaults to red brick answers. Brown and buff brick — common on Charlotte's 1960s–80s ranches and split-levels — has a yellow-brown undertone that fights cool grays and stark whites. Go earthy and low-contrast instead:
Earth & Bronze
Warm cream trim, SW Urbane Bronze accents on gables or porch posts, black door. The bronze bridges brick and roof colors.
Olive Ranch
Cream trim, muted olive shutters (SW Dried Thyme territory), dark wood-stained or oxblood door. Sits naturally against mature Charlotte tree canopy.
If the house has both brown brick and siding (many split-levels do), paint the siding a shade pulled from the lightest brick face rather than a contrasting color — one body color calms a busy elevation.
Schemes for Already-Painted Brick
If your brick is already painted — white, greige, or limewashed — the undertone problem disappears and the full palette opens up. The current sweet spot is a warm white or greige body with black or bronze windows and a natural wood door. For repaint planning, keep the maintenance reality in view: painted brick lasts 5 to 20 years according to HomeGuide, and Bob Vila notes many painted brick exteriors need repainting every 3 to 5 years depending on exposure and prep quality. Budget-wise, HomeGuide puts repainting a brick exterior at $1.50 to $4.50 per square foot, or $2,000 to $8,000 for a typical house.
Thinking about joining the painted-brick club rather than picking around existing paint? That is a separate, mostly irreversible decision — and inside a local historic district it is not yours alone to make, since painting previously unpainted brick goes to the full Historic District Commission as a major project in Dilworth. Our brick paint colors guide covers whether to paint at all and which colors hold up, and the Charlotte brick painting service page explains how the coating side works on masonry.
Cheat Sheet: Brick Type → Trim → Shutters → Door
| Your Brick | Trim | Shutters | Front Door |
|---|---|---|---|
| Orange-red brick | Warm white / cream | Deep green or black | Black, green, navy |
| Deep red brick | Crisp warm white | Black or navy | Black, navy, wood stain |
| Brown / tan brick | Cream / warm off-white | Olive, bronze, or none | Black, oxblood, wood stain |
| Pink-leaning brick | Soft cream (not stark white) | Charcoal or deep green | Charcoal, deep green |
| Painted white brick | Match body or black windows | Black or none | Wood stain, black, sage |
The Front Door Is Worth Extra Attention
The door is the cheapest square footage on the house and carries outsized weight. In a Zillow study where buyers were shown front doors in 11 colors, homes with black front doors could sell for about $6,449 more than expected, and slate blue doors also drew a premium — while pale pink dragged perceived value down sharply (Zillow, 2022). On brick specifically, black, deep green, and navy are the low-risk picks; a glossy or satin sheen on the door gives the scheme a finished look that flat trim paint can't.
What a Trim-and-Shutter Refresh Costs
The good news about brick schemes: you're painting the smallest surfaces on the house. National figures from HomeGuide:
- Exterior trim: $1 to $4 per linear foot, typically $1,000 to $2,500 for a house, according to HomeGuide.
- Window trim: $40 to $150 per window (HomeGuide).
- Shutters: $100 to $200 per set, or $400 to $1,200 for a whole house including prep (HomeGuide).
- For comparison — painting the brick itself: $2,000 to $8,000 (HomeGuide), plus a repaint cycle every 3 to 5 years per Bob Vila.
In other words, a full trim + shutter + door scheme change usually costs a fraction of painting the brick and leaves the lowest-maintenance surface on the house alone. If the trim work uncovers rotten fascia or failing caulk — common on Charlotte homes after humid summers — that gets scoped as carpentry before paint. The Charlotte exterior house painting page breaks down how trim-only projects are scoped and estimated in writing.
Charlotte Notes: Climate, Stock, and HOAs
- Humidity and mildew: North-facing trim and shaded shutters mildew fastest here. Darker shutter colors hide it between washes; trim benefits from a mildew-resistant exterior acrylic from Sherwin-Williams, Benjamin Moore, or PPG.
- Red clay dust: Splash-zone brick and light trim near grade pick up a clay haze. Slightly warm off-whites hide it better than bright white at the foundation line.
- Housing stock: The schemes above map cleanly onto Charlotte's two big brick eras — post-war ranches (Madison Park, Starmount, Cotswold) and 1985–2010 colonials and transitional two-stories (south Charlotte, Fort Mill, Union County).
- HOA approvals: Many newer Charlotte-area neighborhoods require architectural review for shutter and door color changes — black, deep green, and navy sail through most palettes; save the brighter door colors for non-HOA streets or expect a form. Our index of published HOA painting rules shows which communities spell that process out.
Frequently Asked Questions
Warm whites and creams — SW Alabaster, BM White Dove, SW Shoji White — because they echo the mortar instead of fighting the brick's orange undertone. Stark cool whites can make orange-leaning brick look harsh.
Black, deep green, and navy are the reliable three. Avoid red, rust, or burgundy shutters that sit close to the brick color without matching it — near-misses read as mistakes from the street.
Black is the strongest all-around pick — a Zillow study tied black front doors to roughly $6,449 in added perceived value. Deep green, navy, and wood stain are close alternatives depending on the brick.
Earthy, low-contrast partners: warm cream trim, olive or bronze accents, and black, oxblood, or wood-stained doors. Cool grays and bright whites usually clash with brown brick's yellow undertone.
If the brick is sound, update the trim first. HomeGuide puts trim repainting at $1,000–$2,500 versus $2,000–$8,000 to paint the brick — and painted brick commits you to a repaint cycle of every 3–5 years per Bob Vila, while bare brick needs almost none.
Sources
Want a Second Opinion on Your Scheme?
Carolina Renew Painting & Finishes is an owner-led exterior painting company serving the Charlotte NC/SC metro. We work with Sherwin-Williams, Benjamin Moore, and PPG coatings and provide written, itemized estimates — including trim-and-shutter-only scopes on brick homes.
Get Free Estimate 📞 (980) 408-8122